One of the pieces of advice that I casually dropped in the post about how to start and build your medical business was to “Go where you are needed“. This one short sentence is central to finance and fulfillment in the professional life cycle – one of the main taglines that I use for this site.
This is good advice not only when starting independent practice. It should be considered way before then and throughout the stages of your career. That means medical students, residents, early attendings, mid-life crisis attendings with giant motorhomes, and those in the home stretch. It is vital to get this career thing right because, as physicians, our career helps define us whether we’ll admit that or not.
It may sound altruistic. Really though, it is selfish at its worst or symbiotic at its best.
“Going where needed” is behind much of the success that I’ve had in my career. There has been a great sense of fulfillment in having made a difference, but I am also talking about financial success.
Throughout our careers and lives, there is an exchange when we provide something and receive compensation in return. Sometimes, that balance has been grossly in my favour (selfish) and at others it has been an even exchange (symbiotic). Altruism requires a sacrifice with really little or no benefit in return. That has rarely been my experience. When we give, we almost always receive an intrinsic reward in return. I will share how I have slid around on this spectrum while “going where needed”.
You’ll also get a piece of the Loonie Doctor Origin Story. Wolverine would be a good X-men parallel for me. He has Canadian origins, is pretty badass, has sideburns, and lots of body hair that sometimes obscures the six-pack beneath. In Wolverine’s style, this is also not a mushy post about the warm and fuzzies.
The fact is, I am wealthy compared to most doctors. Not because I have been a great investor or a 100% diligent-tax-optimizing-whiz. I try, but am definitely neither of those things. Making good financial choices as an early attending definitely helped. Luck played a role. However, it is also because I decided to make more money by going where I was needed.
How I Came to Medicine
Prior to medical school, I was on track to become a career high school science teacher. I found that I enjoyed teaching OAC (Grade 13) biology. Teaching grade 9 and 10 science – not so much. A big attraction for pursuing medicine was the opportunity to teach high-level medical science as a faculty member. Of course, I was extrapolating my experience of high school teaching to university faculty. I figured that they must get paid better and still have summers off. Plus sabbaticals. Selfish reasons. I really had no clue!
Most medical students talk about how they want to serve and save the world during their medical school interviews. I can say that, having also been on both sides of the interviewing equation. I did enter medicine because I wanted to have a career where I was helping people. However, that was only one aspect of the decision. My real passion was for teaching patients and doctors, as part of that process.
The Medical Student Years
Unfortunately, once in medical school, I found out that this was a time when clinical teaching was not seen as particularly “academic”. I was called to meetings with University leaders where they told me that they had heard that I had great potential but that I needed to up my game.
I was told, “Anyone can be a decent clinician. Anyone can teach… Only the elite special squad of physician ninjas can do research. To work here, you must join the clan.” Ok, I took artistic liberty with the ninja part. Still, my visions of being a nutty medical professor evaporated because I really had no interest in pursuing a clinician-scientist career track.
In fairness, I agree that the clinician-scientist track is probably the toughest path to pursue in academic medicine. However, all of the cogs in the academic medicine gears need to be valued for the machine to function well.
As you can imagine, that climate translated into a paucity of people gunning to be clinician educators. In fact, they had left in droves leaving big gaps and a few staff carrying a huge load. I wanted to “go where needed” because of my interests. Despite the fact that it wasn’t valued yet. This medical student altruism was probably about as selfless as my “go where needed” mantra gets.
While in residency, there was a major need for people to teach the medical students. This need aligned well with my goals. So, I spent considerable time teaching clinical skills and organizing other teaching sessions. At the same time, there were changes afoot within the University.
The teaching crisis had reached a point by the final years of my residency that there was a new emphasis being placed upon developing clinical educational leadership. I was poised to take advantage of that in getting the plum job that I coveted.
This was when I first received the “Go where you are needed” advice.
To set the backdrop. At this time, resident physician work-hour restrictions were just starting and lifestyle balance had suddenly become all the rage. In my PGY-1 year there were suddenly rules about not doing more than 1 in 4 on-call. By PGY-2 they were being somewhat followed and in my PGY-3 year we were even going home post-call by noon sometimes. This was a major counter-cultural push by my resident peers at the time. Those who didn’t follow all of the rules were frowned upon and the derogatory term “macho-doctor” was applied. Our resident union even had posters in the lounge to shame dissenters.
Within that backdrop, I was chatting with one of my faculty mentor/champions about where I saw my career going. We discussed what I wanted in terms of lifestyle, which types of clinical practice I found most interesting, how I wanted to teach because I enjoyed that. My focus was really on what I wanted out of my career and this line of discussion was a well-worn road from discussions amongst my contemporaries.
He then blew up my smoothly-paved-thought-road by simply saying, “You know. You haven’t mentioned the one thing that we all talked about while at your stage… Where am I needed?” I was left speechless. A rarity.
That shook me up because I had slipped from my altruistic-medical-student-thinking into a self-centered mode.
Neither extreme was optimal. This caused me to recalibrate.
In medicine, a purely altruistic approach of filling needs with little return can be sustained for short periods. However, the need is usually infinite and filling it may, or may not, be valued at a given time or by a given person. Unchecked, that can become medical martyrdom and contribute to burn-out.
A self-centered approach is also ultimately detrimental. You need empathy and compassion to practice medicine well. Further, one of the greatest rewards for practicing medicine is the feeling of self-worth generated by making meaningful contributions. Those who practice medicine for money without empathy or regard for the rewards to their karma don’t last long. Most leave, or if really bad, they get forced out.
What is optimal is a balanced symbiotic relationship. Ideally, “Going where needed” means that you fill a need and have your needs met by doing so.
What did I learn from my early dances with “go where you are needed?”
- Doing work that is interesting or challenging is still often cited when people talk about job fulfillment.
- That work is more fulfilling when it fills a need.
- That need may be undervalued in terms of financial or professional recognition, but those imbalances often right themselves eventually.
A healthy sustainable medical career involves finding symbiosis. To do that, you must not only “go where you are needed” but you must also be rewarded for doing so. We make many choices with consequences that influence our chances of success. Often, we won’t get them all perfect. That is ok. A sacrifice-reward imbalance can be tolerated for periods of time. However, too much altruism leads to a burnt out doctor while selfishness simply makes for a bad one.
In the next chapter of the Loonie Doctor Wolverine origin story, the rubber really hits the road as I move from resident to attending physician.
That one piece of advice from my mentor, “Go where you are needed“, has guided me since.
It has propelled my career to make it richly fulfilling, and well, made me rich. Join me next week to learn how.
I did 1 in 2 call for many weeks during my internship. It was rather unpleasant but also a blur.
My husband went where he was needed. It was where he could get a job.
I went where I wanted since I was a self employed female GP.
We want a picture of the six pack abs under the Wolverine fur thanks.
Hey Dr. MB! Sadly the six pack is hidden by more than fur at present. Preparation for hibernation and all…
I think most physicians as a whole are altruistic as if it was purely w play for money there are far better returns in other fields of work than medicine when you factor the delay in earning potential during our training.
The things that really infuse enthusiasm in my day are those great cases where you make a call and really impact the outcome of a patient. As a radiologist finding something that is unexpected that really changes a patients outcome is a great reward in and of itself, and I think falls in line with your symbiosis concept.
The days I feel burned out are the ones where I am just reading case after case that are not fulfilling and just doing it as part of the job and to get paid (selfish in your concept). So I agree with your line of thinking that if you are solely doing this in your practice you will not last as long because it is unfulfilling
Your description of the thrill of making an impact plus getting paid for it is a great example of symbiosis in medicine. We are fortunate that most of medicine is like this.
Another good piece of advice that I got along the way was this. When choosing a specialty, don’t choose it based just on what you love about it (that is the easy part). Choose a specialty where the “grind” type cases are tolerable because that is what will drag on you in the long run. Many of those grind cases are where we collect money, but aren’t really helping people (selfish). Unnecessary studies are a big one that irks my radiology friends. In emergency medicine, it was people coming into ER who really didn’t need ER services. In my field, it would be families forcing us to do procedures on dying people that don’t really help them. You get paid for all this. In fact, it is often the “easy money”, but it doesn’t sit well and would burn you out if that was a dominant part of your job.
Thanks for the great comment!
I’m really enjoying this series about transitioning from resident to attending. They are coming at a particularly timely moment for me as I’m set to graduate from a specialty next June – so these topics are on my mind.
I like how you have articulated the concept of “go where you’re needed”. I have unconsciously done this throughout my training but never articulated it quite so clearly. For me, this concept was extremely important when picking my residency. I was debating between two fields – one of which had limited job opportunities (radiation oncology) and another (psychiatry) where jobs are plenty. I ended up choosing the latter specialty, in large part because of job availability and am extremely happy for the flexibility that this has allowed.
I have also continued this process as I am in the process of obtaining advanced training in a field that is needed at my local institution. I am “going where it’s needed” even if it is not a physical location.
Thank you for articulating this, and I will be sure to provide this advice to younger residents and trainees.
Right on StatsDoc! You get it and are destined to have a great career! I think you will really identify with my next post where the “Go Where Needed” concept is the dissected as my career path mutates to its current state.